How to Remove a Commit from Git?

Sometimes, mistakes or unnecessary changes make their way into a commit, and the best course of action is to remove it. Git provides several ways to delete or modify commits in a repository, whether they’re local changes, committed but not pushed, or already shared on a remote repository. This blog will explain how to safely remove unwanted commits from your Git history and help you choose the right method for each scenario.

---

Why Remove a Commit?

Removing a commit may be necessary for reasons such as:

• Accidental Commits: You mistakenly added debug code or an incomplete feature.
• Security Concerns: Sensitive information, such as API keys or passwords, was accidentally committed.
• Cleanup: You want to maintain a clean history by removing unnecessary or redundant changes.

With Git, you have the flexibility to remove or modify commits in ways that preserve or rewrite history, depending on your needs and whether or not the commit has already been shared.

---

Key Methods to Remove a Commit in Git

Here are the primary methods you can use to remove a commit, along with guidance on when each approach is appropriate:

1. git reset: Useful for removing local commits by rewriting history.
2. git revert: Ideal for safely removing commits in a shared history, such as on GitHub, without rewriting history.
3. git rebase: Advanced method for editing or removing specific commits within your branch history.

---

Method 1: Using git reset for Local Commits (Rewriting History)

If the unwanted commit is still local and hasn’t been pushed to a remote repository, git reset is a fast and effective way to remove it by rewriting history.

How to Use git reset

1. Identify the Commit Hash: Use git log to find the commit hash of the point in history you want to reset to. This commit should be the last one you want to keep.

   git log

2. Perform the Reset: You have three options depending on how you want to handle the changes from the unwanted commits:

• Hard Reset: Completely removes commits and discards all changes in the working directory. git reset --hard <commit-hash>
• Mixed Reset: Removes commits but keeps the changes unstaged in the working directory. git reset --mixed <commit-hash>
• Soft Reset: Removes commits but keeps the changes staged in the working directory. git reset --soft <commit-hash>

2. Push with Force (if Necessary): If you’ve already pushed the commits to a remote branch, you’ll need to use --force to push the changes. Be cautious with force pushes if working in a shared branch, as it rewrites history and can disrupt collaborators.

   git push origin <branch-name> --force

When to Use git reset

• For local commits that have not been pushed to a remote repository.
• For situations where you want to completely remove commits from history, such as when fixing errors before sharing changes with others.

---

Method 2: Using git revert for Safe Rollbacks (Non-Destructive)

If the commit has already been pushed to a shared repository (like GitHub) and you don’t want to rewrite history, git revert is a safe, non-destructive way to remove it. git revert doesn’t delete the commit but creates a new commit that undoes its changes. This approach is especially suitable for team environments.

How to Use git revert

1. Identify the Commit Hash: Use git log to locate the commit hash of the commit you want to revert.

   git log

2. Revert the Commit: Run git revert followed by the commit hash. This will open a text editor where you can enter a commit message for the revert operation.

   git revert <commit-hash>

• Git creates a new commit that undoes the specified commit’s changes.
• This method maintains a clear history and allows others to see the removal of the change.

1. Push the Changes: Since git revert doesn’t rewrite history, you can push the new commit without needing to use force.

   git push origin <branch-name>

When to Use git revert

• For shared branches or remote repositories where rewriting history is not desirable.
• When you want to maintain a clear record of changes while removing or undoing specific modifications.

---

Method 3: Using git rebase to Edit History (Advanced)

git rebase is a powerful tool for editing, reordering, or removing commits from your branch history. This approach is best suited for local changes that haven’t been pushed yet. Rebase is an advanced operation, so use it with care, especially in a collaborative environment.

How to Use git rebase

1. Start an Interactive Rebase: Begin an interactive rebase, specifying the number of commits you want to edit. For example, to rebase the last three commits:

   git rebase -i HEAD~3

2. Select the Commit to Remove: In the editor that opens, you’ll see a list of recent commits. You can choose to edit, remove, or rearrange these commits by following the instructions provided.

• To delete a commit, change pick to drop next to the unwanted commit and save the file.

2. Complete the Rebase: Git will reapply each commit after the removed one. You may need to resolve any conflicts if they arise.
3. Push with Force (if Necessary): If the branch was already shared on a remote, use a force-push. Communicate with your team if you’re force-pushing changes to a shared branch.

   git push origin <branch-name> --force

When to Use git rebase

• For modifying recent commit history before pushing to a remote repository.
• For complex history edits, such as reordering or squashing commits.

---

Summary of Git Commands for Removing Commits

Command	Description
git reset --hard <commit-hash>	Removes all commits after specified hash and discards changes.
git reset --soft <commit-hash>	Removes commits but keeps changes staged.
git reset --mixed <commit-hash>	Removes commits and unstages changes but keeps them in the working directory.
git revert <commit-hash>	Creates a new commit that undoes the changes of a specific commit.
git rebase -i HEAD~<n>	Allows interactive rebase for editing or removing recent commits.

---

Important Considerations When Removing Commits

• Communication is Key: If you’re working in a shared environment, discuss changes to commit history with your team, especially if you’re force-pushing after using git reset or git rebase.
• Backup Your Work: If you’re new to these commands, consider creating a backup branch before making irreversible changes to the commit history.
• Understand Each Method’s Impacts:
• git reset is ideal for local changes but dangerous for shared branches.
• git revert is safe for shared branches but retains a record of the reverted commit.
• git rebase provides control over history but is best for advanced users.

---

Conclusion

Removing a commit from Git is straightforward once you know the right approach for each scenario. Whether using git reset for local edits, git revert for safe rollbacks, or git rebase for interactive editing, Git offers versatile ways to manage your commit history. By understanding these tools, you can maintain a clean, professional history in your projects and ensure that your codebase is as organized and efficient as possible.

Mastering these commands will give you the confidence to navigate complex version control situations, ensuring that your project’s history is both accurate and efficient.