How to Remove a Commit from GitHub?

In software development, version control is essential, but sometimes a commit needs to be removed from a GitHub repository. Whether it’s due to mistakes, sensitive information, or unnecessary changes, removing a commit from GitHub requires a careful approach to avoid disrupting the history of the repository, especially when collaborating with others.

This blog post will cover various methods to remove commits from a GitHub repository, explain when each method is appropriate, and provide tips for best practices.

---

Why Would You Need to Remove a Commit?

Here are some common reasons why you might want to remove a commit from GitHub:

1. Sensitive Information: If a commit contains sensitive data like passwords or API keys, it’s essential to remove it.
2. Mistaken Changes: Sometimes, unintended changes are committed that need to be removed.
3. Reverting Changes: To undo recent updates that impacted project stability.
4. Tidying Commit History: Streamlining the history by removing unnecessary or redundant commits before sharing with others.

---

Understanding the Impact of Removing Commits

Before we proceed, let’s understand the implications of removing commits:

• Rewrite History: Removing commits rewrites the history, so changes may affect anyone else working on the same branch.
• Local and Remote Changes: If the commit has been pushed to GitHub, the local and remote repositories must be kept in sync.
• Care with Public Repositories: When working in public repositories or collaborative environments, ensure that removing a commit doesn’t impact other contributors.

---

Prerequisites

1. Git Installed: Make sure Git is installed on your local machine.
2. Cloned Repository: You need a local clone of the repository where the commit is located.

If you don’t already have a local clone, you can clone it using:

git clone https://github.com/username/repository-name.git

Replace username/repository-name with your GitHub username and repository name.

---

Method 1: Removing the Most Recent Commit (Using git reset)

If you need to remove the latest commit and haven’t pushed it to GitHub, this is a straightforward process.

Steps:

1. Open Git Bash: Open Git Bash or any command-line interface where Git is available.
2. Navigate to the Repository:

   cd path/to/your-repository

3. Use git reset to Remove the Last Commit: To remove the most recent commit but keep the changes in your working directory:

   git reset --soft HEAD~1

This command removes the commit but leaves your changes in the working directory so you can edit or commit them again if needed.

4. Force Push the Changes to GitHub: If the commit was already pushed to GitHub, you need to force-push to update the remote repository:

   git push origin branch-name --force

Replace branch-name with the branch you’re working on (usually main or master).

Note: Use --force with caution, as it will overwrite the remote branch history.

---

Method 2: Removing a Specific Commit in History (Using git rebase)

If you need to remove a specific commit from the middle of your history, git rebase is the recommended approach. Rebase lets you modify the commit history without affecting other changes.

Steps:

1. Open Git Bash and Navigate to the Repository:

   cd path/to/your-repository

2. Start an Interactive Rebase: Start an interactive rebase from the point where the unwanted commit is located. For example, if you want to edit the last 3 commits:

   git rebase -i HEAD~3

3. Edit the Interactive Rebase File: An editor will open with a list of commits. Locate the commit you want to remove and change the word pick at the beginning of the line to drop. This will remove the commit from the history.
4. Save and Close the Editor: Save the file and close the editor. Git will reapply the commits without the dropped commit.
5. Force Push the Updated History to GitHub: Since this alters the history, a force push is required to update the remote repository:

   git push origin branch-name --force

Again, replace branch-name with the branch you’re modifying.

---

Method 3: Reverting a Commit (Using git revert)

If you don’t want to rewrite the history but instead want to undo the changes from a specific commit, you can use git revert. This method creates a new commit that undoes the changes in the specified commit without removing it from the history, making it ideal for collaborative environments.

Steps:

1. Identify the Commit Hash: Use git log to find the hash of the commit you want to revert. The hash is a unique identifier for each commit.

   git log

2. Revert the Commit: Run the git revert command followed by the commit hash:

   git revert commit-hash

Replace commit-hash with the specific hash of the commit you want to undo.

3. Push the Revert Commit to GitHub: Once the revert commit is created, push it to the remote repository:

   git push origin branch-name

This keeps the history intact and allows collaborators to see both the original and revert commit.

---

Choosing the Right Method

Situation	Recommended Method
Latest commit not pushed	git reset
Remove specific commit from history	git rebase
Undo changes without altering history	git revert
Remove sensitive information from all commits	History Rewrite with Filter Branch or BFG

---

Tips and Best Practices

• Use Force Push Carefully: Always communicate with collaborators before using --force, as it alters the shared history.
• Keep Backups: Before making significant changes, consider creating a backup branch in case something goes wrong.
• Revert Over Reset/Rebase in Collaborative Projects: If others are working on the branch, git revert is safer since it preserves history.
• Use BFG Repo-Cleaner for Sensitive Data: If you need to remove sensitive data like API keys from all history, use a tool like BFG Repo-Cleaner, which is designed for safely removing sensitive information from Git repositories.

---

Summary

Removing a commit from GitHub is a powerful operation that can be accomplished in different ways depending on your specific needs. Here’s a quick recap:

• Use git reset for undoing the latest commit if it hasn’t been pushed, and use --force if you need to update GitHub.
• Use git rebase to remove a specific commit from history and rewrite your commit history as needed.
• Use git revert to safely undo changes while preserving the commit history, ideal for collaborative settings.